Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of eligible case-control studies on the association between physically demanding occupations and the development of osteoarthritis

From: Physically demanding occupations among females and sex-related differences to develop osteoarthritis of the hip: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study

Country

Population

Description Cases vs. Controls

Exposition (occupational group) vs. reference

Quality score

Total (S/A/E)

Elsner 1995

Germany [34]

Patients of an orthopaedic practice

N=418 (220/198)

Response cases: 60 %, control: n.d.

Age (range) of cases: 30 % - > 60 years with younger controls

Women (%): 189 (45 %)a

Nurses and kindergarten teacher: 18 (100 %)a

Health care: 10 (100 %)a

Retail worker: 27 (71 %)a

Workers in hotels, gastronomy and households: 22 (61.1 %)a

Occupations in textile industry: 13 (100 %)a

Cleaner: 8 (61.5 %)a

Hairdresser: 6 (100 %)a

cases: patients with hip symptoms and radiographic signs of HOA vs.

controls: persons without hip symptoms from a general practice and an ophthalmologist, church community

1989-1993

Questionnaire on occupational history, occupational groups named by ≥ 5 persons vs. all other men or women

5 (1/2/2)

Franklin 2010

Iceland [35]

All patients and their first-degree relatives ≥ 60 years

Response cases: 33 %

N= 2490 (1408/1082)

Age: cases: 71-75/ controls: 71 years

Women (%): 1424 (832/592) (57.2 %)

Managers and professionals: 115 (54.5 %)

Farmer: 242a (46.7 %)a

Technicians and associate professionals: 196a (63.8 %)a

Service and shop worker: 246a (78.8 %)a

Craft worker: 196a (45.7 %)a

Operator and unskilled labour: 162 (53 %)

cases: all patients with TKR or THR due to OA, at surgery (1967-1998) vs.

controls: first-degree relatives

1998

Questionnaire on occupational history, longest held occupations coded into 8 groups,

6 groups vs. manager and professionals (e.g. teachers, doctors, nurses)

10 (3/4/3)

  1. acalculated by the authors
  2. A adjustment, E exposition, HOA Hip osteoarthritis, n.d no data, S selection, THR total hip replacement